A Long Journey Home

A 24 year old male discusses his fascinating spiritual journey from Atheism, to Buddhism, to Judaism. 

Until the age of 19 years old, I was a staunch Atheist. [I believed] the one thing for me to do in this existence is to try to be happy, it doesn't matter how I achieve that happiness even at the expense of someone else. … Just prior to my 19th birthday, I had what our western secular psychologists would call a nervous breakdown and what eastern mystics would refer to as a revelation. … My perception of reality was forever shattered from that moment onward…By a strange twist of fate shortly after the millennium new year. I almost literally fell into the topic of Buddhism. Being Jewish with a poor, almost non-existent understanding of what Judaism is really about, … I was fascinated by the philosophies I was ‘re’discovering within the context of Buddhism. I truly felt as though my thoughts since youth had been printed out not just in a single book, but had been expanded and expounded by an entire religious/spiritual path.

I quickly began implementing the 'spiritual technology' that I was learning from various Buddhist books, and taught myself how to meditate, of course based on instruction from these books. Shortly afterward (fall of 2000), I headed to Nepal and India to further explore the depths of these teachings.
Now equipped with a firm understanding of the nature of karma, it only made sense that upon my return home (Toronto, spring of 2001) I would start exploring the deeper reasons for my given identity in this world: a Jewish boy, born and raised in Toronto by a Jewish family in a Jewish neighbourhood, with moderately religious grandparents on my fathers side.

Shortly after my return from Nepal and India, I enrolled in a Kabbalah course and began learning about Jewish spirituality and philosophy. I was struck by the similarities (l'havdil) between the deeper Buddhist philosophies and Judaism, I really could not believe that Judaism had such depth of logic and thought.

I continued learning about Jewish spirituality for several years, however I lacked belief in G-d and this began to be a very frustrating point. Why should I become a religiously observant Jew when I have a perfectly good path in Buddhism? If there is no G-d but only an underlying spiritual existence in this world, why be obligated by the stringencies of an observant Jewish life when I could simply return to India where I could be surrounded by 'spiritual' people and continue meditating to deeper and deeper levels? …

This is where Aish HaTorah [literally, “Fire of the Torah” – Jewish law – an organization devoted to educating Jews on rediscovering their faith through learning and knowledge] stepped into my life. In the fall of 2003, I went to see their 'Discovery' presentation where they cover various topics on the legitimacy and divinity of the Torah and its author, G-d.

I began learning about these 'proofs' and reading up on the 'evidence' for the viability of this claim. Shortly afterward, I went directly to Israel to their Jerusalem head office where I was able to discuss my questions with their leading rabbis on the topic. They gave me the intellectual information. I acquired the knowledge … 

The knowledge of the mind must be converted into the emotions of the heart, otherwise life’s insights and realities are all for naught. It was precisely this emotional conversion in the summer of 2004 that finally led to my conclusion that I believed in G-d and would for the rest of my life be devoted to serving that G-d to the best of my ability. I officially became an observant Jew.

In contrast to this previous post, this story describes how increased knowledge leads to increased faith. I find it interesting that he discovers mystical parallels between Buddhism and Judaism through Kabbalah. Even more interesting, is how this very long path led him back to his roots. Maybe there is something to say about karma.

Explore posts in the same categories: Atheism, Buddhism, Judaism, Kabbalah

4 Comments on “A Long Journey Home”

  1. Anonymous Says:

    As far as I understand Buddhism is agnostic on there being (or not being) what we neutrally refer to as a Supreme Being. By that light one could use Buddhism to supplement Judaism without any conflict, unless of course one happens to be (or happens to want to be) an extremely orthodox Jew.
    Probably our most famous example of this hybrid in action would be Leonard Cohen, who resided for years in the Zen monastery atop Mt. Baldy in California. He recently published a book of poetry entitled Book of Longing (2006) and, since this entry turns on belief whether or not there is God, I wish to share one of the more darkly humours poems on that matter:

    FUN

    It is so much fun
    to believe in G-d
    You must try it sometime
    Try it now
    and find out whether
    or not
    G-d wants you
    to believe in Him

  2. gumby Says:

    That is quite interesting. I think that perhaps he wanted very much to be brought back into judaism rather than it pulling him, since he went to Israel to speak to the Leading Rabbi’s. Karma should not be under-rated for sure.


  3. [...] This post further explores the relationship between knowledge and religion. Two previous posts have explored the same idea: one strengthening faith, and one weakening faith. To this respondent, his faith acts as a moral compass that provides guidance and brings clarity to dilemmas that he faces in life. The knowledge that he has acquired enables him to develop a more subtle and nuanced understanding of Catholicism. This allows him to function in an imperfect world. Explore posts in the same categories: Christianity, Catholicism [...]

  4. yitzchak shlomo Says:

    i find it very disenchanting reading the many posts on this site and specifically the first comment to my post here.
    first of all, buddhism and Judaism do NOT go together. it would be neccessary for one to actually know something about observant practice and philisophical outlook in both in order to make any sort of educated comment, which apparently this individual does not.
    secondly, it seems quite apparent that the vast majority of people in this site and, as it were, the world at large have not, and do not approach these topics with any sort of objective, logic based, reference point. most of these posts are, quite unfortantely, subjective and opinion based. if one is to make a decision about something that has such grave implications on ones life it would be proper for them to search for objective evidence and logically stable proofs and arguments before forming such short-sighted subjective conclusions.
    subjectivity and objectivity can be compared to building a house (which metaphorically would be the final idea/thought/belief). if the foundation is built upon constantly shifting materials (subjectivity) then the house will quickly collapse as it is simply and elaborate contruct built upon faulty ideals. however, if that foundation is solid and firm (objectivity) then the construct upon it has substance and legitimacy and will last forever.
    spiritual journeys are nice, but like everything else in this existance, if it’s based on subjectivity and relitavism then it is essentially based on nothing.
    be careful before you make such hasty conclusions.


Comment: